Search Ideas
55 ideas match your query.:
Maybe LLM coders aren't stealing value but instead creating it?
Copyright just seems so arbitrary to me. The whole edifice of law around it. Why 70 years after the author's death? What's "original"? When is it "my own words?"
I wasn't aware that I signed such a contract when buying a book. I think for the contract to be valid I have to be aware of the conditions, no?
Okay well I have never thought of it in those terms. I definitely think NDAs should be enforceable.
Lol no, I'm trying to understand your point. You're saying that buying a book is a bit like signing an NDA, where I can be held liable for breach of contract if I disclose information. Did I get that right?
Lol no, I'm trying to understand your point.
So it's not me who's pirating the book that is violating her right. It's whoever uploaded it for me to download it, right?
Okay so without referring to current legislation. I understand that it is currently illegal, just like tax evasion, but that won't go far in persuading me that it isn't right.
Why? I don't get that. She's not losing anything.
Am I committing aggression against JK Rowling if I pirate a PDF copy of Harry Potter?
Maybe? Kinda? Not sure.
You don't get to use your knife to aggress on others, that much is clear. So perhaps this can be understood as a right of others to do certain things with your property.
I can also think of ways this could be misused.
I'm not sure, seriously. I'm open to suggestions.
There's lots of things that I think people shouldn't do yet should still be legal.
I don't care about current law, there are lots of dumb laws. I care about what's right and why.
No. I don't expect to find it, but that doesn't make it less true. That's how I make sense of the difference between IP and real property.
The issue is scarcity. Digital money is also scarce since you cannot double spend it. If it wasn't scarce, it wouldn't be money and neither would it be private property.
That could be happening though, so agreed that it isn't a good argument.
Just that if it was so crucial for innovation then you'd expect innovation to suffer from all the copyright infringement that is going on.