Search

Ideas that are…

Search Ideas


403 ideas match your query.:

Drugs are a net negative for society.
(This branch of the conversation has been moved to #4137)

#4139·Benjamin DaviesOP revised 9 days ago·Original #4063

The purpose of the law isn’t to minimise negatives and maximise positives. The purpose of the law is to uphold the rights of people.

#4138·Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago·Criticism

Drugs are a net negative for society.

#4137·Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago·CriticismCriticized1

Doesn’t need to be arbitrary emojis, it could just be a handful that you choose, each being a different flavour of acknowledgement.

Thumbs up,
Thinking emoji,
Mind-blown emoji,
Etc.

Edit: X spaces are an example of a limited set of emojis working well.

#4107·Benjamin Davies revised 9 days ago·Original #4104·CriticismCriticized2Archived

Doesn’t need to be arbitrary emojis, it could just be a handful that you choose, each being a different flavour of acknowledgement.

Thumbs up,
Thinking emoji,
Mind-blown emoji,
Etc.

#4104·Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago·CriticismCriticized1Archived

I like the acknowledged/unacknowledged idea.

#4103·Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago·Archived

You could think up a design for a self-replicating machine and then build it. Assuming you made no critical mistakes, you have made a self-replicator that hasn’t self-replicated yet.

It is considered a replicator based on what it can do, rather than on what it has done.

#4094·Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago·Criticism

Advocacy is not the same as telling people what to think.

#4092·Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago·Criticism

Because decision-making is a special case of, ie follows the same logic as, truth-seeking, you can use such trees for decision-making, too.

This sentence is difficult to follow. Could it be made simpler or broken up?

#4091·Benjamin Davies, 9 days ago·Criticism

Is there a reason the analogy follows from open vs closed societies, to open vs closed people? A society is not a person.

#4090·Benjamin DaviesOP, 9 days ago·CriticismCriticized1

Those who advocate making most/all drugs illegal tend to think alcohol should remain legal, despite alcohol having many of the same problems as drugs.

#4068·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago

Not prohibited by law.

#4067·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago

The purpose of the law isn’t to minimise negatives and maximise positives. The purpose of the law is to uphold the rights of people.

#4065·Benjamin DaviesOP revised 10 days ago·Original #4064·Criticism

The purpose of the law isn’t to minimise negatives and maximise positives. The purpose of the law is to uphold the rights of people.

#4064·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago·Criticized1

Drugs are a net negative for society.

#4063·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago·Criticized3

Legalising drugs will bring lawful competition to cartels and gangs, breaking geographical monopolies that perpetuate other (actual) criminal activity.

#4062·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago

If they violate rights they should be punished by the law, that applies regardless of if they take drugs or not.

#4060·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago·Criticism

People on drugs violate the rights of others way more often.

#4059·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago·CriticismCriticized1

All drugs should be legal because people have a right to do what they want, as long as it isn’t violating the rights of others.

#4058·Benjamin DaviesOP, 10 days ago· Battle tested

This is not exactly true. The business still needs to produce something people want to buy, at a price they will accept. This is separate from competition.

Another way to say that is: all businesses are in competition with all others at the broadest level.

If you like Snickers bars, but they suddenly 5x in price, it isn’t necessarily true that you will buy a different chocolate bar. You might go to the bakery instead, or use that money to put a little more fuel in your car.

#4009·Benjamin DaviesOP revised 13 days ago·Original #4008·Criticism

This is not exactly true. The business still needs to produce something people want to buy, at a price they will accept. This is separate from competition.

Another way to say that is: all businesses are in competition with all others at the broadest level.

If you liked Snickers bars, but they suddenly 5x in price, it isn’t necessarily true that you will buy a different chocolate bar. You might go to the bakery instead, or use that money to put a little more fuel in your car.

#4008·Benjamin DaviesOP, 13 days ago·CriticismCriticized1

Thank you, I think that is an important clarification.

#4007·Benjamin Davies, 13 days ago

There is overlap but I don’t think that is necessarily a bad thing. Many virtues overlap. The purpose of identifying them is to draw focus to different aspects of virtues as such. Conscientiousness and thoroughness are quite similar, but I think different enough to merit mentioning both.

Excellence and pride are more similar IMO, but I think that it is fine to feature both.

#3987·Benjamin DaviesOP revised 13 days ago·Original #3145·Criticism

Bounties should be clear about what currency they are being paid out in.

#3986·Benjamin Davies, 13 days ago·CriticismCriticized1Archived