Activity Feed

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2659.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream top-level ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

#2659·Dennis HackethalOP revised 7 days ago

cmd + f won’t work reliably.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2635.

I could lazy load ideas: only load the parts of the page that would be visible on the current viewport. Then load more parts as the user scrolls.

#2635·Dennis HackethalOP, 9 days ago

That means cmd + f won’t always work.

  Dennis Hackethal commented on criticism #2630.

Discussions are getting slower to render as they grow. It’s a rendering issue (not a db issue).

#2630·Dennis HackethalOP revised 9 days ago

The top level ideas could be rendered as turbo frames of ideas#show.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2675.

I could have a separate route at /ideas/:id/isolated which renders only the idea without any parents or children. And then a discussion could render a bunch of deeply nested turbo frames loading that route.

#2675·Dennis HackethalOP, 6 days ago

For large discussions, wouldn’t that flood the server with requests?

  Dennis Hackethal commented on criticism #2630.

Discussions are getting slower to render as they grow. It’s a rendering issue (not a db issue).

#2630·Dennis HackethalOP revised 9 days ago

I could have a separate route at /ideas/:id/isolated which renders only the idea without any parents or children. And then a discussion could render a bunch of deeply nested turbo frames loading that route.

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #2672.

The thread contains a suggested solution: use authenticated do … blocks in routes.rb instead of before_action :authenticate_user! in controllers.

The thread contains a suggested solution: use authenticated do … blocks in routes.rb instead of before_action :authenticate_user! in controllers.

It’s probably a good idea to do this anyway to avoid divulging the existence of routes that unauthenticated users don’t need to know exist. (They will get a 404 instead of a 401.)

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #2670.

Incompatible with Devise authentication: https://github.com/heartcombo/devise/issues/2332

#2670·Dennis HackethalOP, 6 days ago

The thread contains a suggested solution: use authenticated do … blocks in routes.rb instead of before_action :authenticate_user! in controllers.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2659.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream top-level ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

#2659·Dennis HackethalOP revised 7 days ago

JS modules are always deferred and unusable until the page is fully loaded. As a result, comment buttons and gutters won’t work while ideas are still streaming onto the page.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2659.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream top-level ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

#2659·Dennis HackethalOP revised 7 days ago

Incompatible with Devise authentication: https://github.com/heartcombo/devise/issues/2332

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #2669.

Feature idea: pay people to address criticisms (either revise an idea and check off criticisms or counter-criticize).

  Dennis Hackethal commented on idea #2659.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream top-level ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

#2659·Dennis HackethalOP revised 7 days ago

This page used to take ~3.5 seconds to load. Now it renders within 600ms :)

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #2653.

‘Veritula’ is a difficult name, people don’t know how to pronounce it. They usually can’t remember it.

‘Veritula’ is a difficult name, people don’t know how to spell or pronounce it. They can’t easily remember it.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2654.

Idea: ‘The Second Renaissance’, ‘2nd Renaissance’, ‘2R’ for short.

#2654·Dennis HackethalOP, 7 days ago

‘Renaissance’ isn’t exactly easy to spell either.

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #444.

The following commits should address this:

  • 3af3966 Clarify in title that someone revised an idea (rathen than originated idea)

    The HTML title now says ‘Idea x revised by…’

  • 6c70cea Underneath idea, indicate that someone revised an idea (rather than submitted it)

    It says ‘Dennis Hackethal, 1 day ago’ for new ideas, ‘Dennis Hackethal revised 1 day ago’ for revisions

  • d20d386 Explain that users can revise each others’ ideas

    As part of the alert on the revision page, when the user is about to revise someone else’s idea.

  • c5748e3 Turn ‘revise’ link into ‘revise their idea’ when it’s someone else’s idea

    Underneath each idea.

  • e0fbd41 List user under each revision in version history

    So that each version is clearly attributed to the corresponding user.

  • 06d3241 List contributors at top of version history

    Comma-separated list to see all contributors at a glance. Eg see here

The following commits should address this:

  • 3af3966 Clarify in title that someone revised an idea (rather than originated idea)

    The HTML title now says ‘Idea x revised by…’

  • 6c70cea Underneath idea, indicate that someone revised an idea (rather than submitted it)

    It says ‘Dennis Hackethal, 1 day ago’ for new ideas, ‘Dennis Hackethal revised 1 day ago’ for revisions

  • d20d386 Explain that users can revise each others’ ideas

    As part of the alert on the revision page, when the user is about to revise someone else’s idea.

  • c5748e3 Turn ‘revise’ link into ‘revise their idea’ when it’s someone else’s idea

    Underneath each idea.

  • e0fbd41 List user under each revision in version history

    So that each version is clearly attributed to the corresponding user.

  • 06d3241 List contributors at top of version history

    Comma-separated list to see all contributors at a glance. Eg see here

  Dennis Hackethal revised criticism #2658.

Changing the view logic so that the controller can stream each deeply nested idea separately sounds non-trivial. It’s not clear to me how to do that currently, It may be possible someday if I adjust Hiccdown to allow the use of enumerators or something like that.

Changing the view logic so that the controller can stream each deeply nested idea separately sounds non-trivial. It’s not clear to me how to do that currently. It may be possible someday if I adjust Hiccdown to allow the use of enumerators or something like that.

  Dennis Hackethal revised idea #2646. The revision addresses idea #2658.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream top-level ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2646.

I could use ActionController::Live to stream ideas to the page one by one. Instant page load.

#2646·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago

Changing the view logic so that the controller can stream each deeply nested idea separately sounds non-trivial. It’s not clear to me how to do that currently, It may be possible someday if I adjust Hiccdown to allow the use of enumerators or something like that.

  Dennis Hackethal criticized idea #2635.

I could lazy load ideas: only load the parts of the page that would be visible on the current viewport. Then load more parts as the user scrolls.

#2635·Dennis HackethalOP, 9 days ago

Complex, requires non-trivial scroll listeners correlated to deeply nested ideas.

  Dennis Hackethal commented on criticism #1954.

I see the value in having quiet areas to think, I agree that it is important, but I at times find the quiet distracting. I sometimes work better in environments that have some level of noise, nothing like a club, more like a somewhat crowded cafe. So are you talking about “quieter” environments such as a cafe, or are you talking about complete silence in your observation?

#1954·Lola Trimble, about 1 month ago

Just saw this app that lets you play ambient sounds at home: https://x.com/mirdhaaakanksha/status/1983238682154021218

  Dennis Hackethal commented on criticism #2653.

‘Veritula’ is a difficult name, people don’t know how to pronounce it. They usually can’t remember it.

#2653·Dennis HackethalOP, 7 days ago

Idea: ‘Return to Reason’, ‘RR’

  Dennis Hackethal commented on criticism #2653.

‘Veritula’ is a difficult name, people don’t know how to pronounce it. They usually can’t remember it.

#2653·Dennis HackethalOP, 7 days ago

Idea: ‘The Second Renaissance’, ‘2nd Renaissance’, ‘2R’ for short.

  Dennis Hackethal submitted criticism #2653.

‘Veritula’ is a difficult name, people don’t know how to pronounce it. They usually can’t remember it.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #2647.

Including that module significantly slows down hot reloads on all pages. I need a tight feedback loop in dev.

#2647·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago

Replacing a raw SQL query in Idea.tree with a standard ActiveRecord query solves this issue.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #2650.

After resetting my working directory and beginning to implement streams a second time, I can no longer reproduce this issue, despite reasonable attempts to reproduce it.

#2650·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago

I’ve since been able to reproduce the issue after all. Running a raw SQL query in Idea.tree in combination with the inclusion of the Live module seems to mess with Rails’s reloader.

  Dennis Hackethal addressed criticism #2647.

Including that module significantly slows down hot reloads on all pages. I need a tight feedback loop in dev.

#2647·Dennis HackethalOP, 8 days ago

After resetting my working directory and beginning to implement streams a second time, I can no longer reproduce this issue, despite reasonable attempts to reproduce it.